
Stonewall Riots, Photo by Bettye Lane
I recently had a brief email encounter with a reader that almost made me cry. It all started with a simple misunderstanding when she read an old blog of mine. It was one of those old blogs from when I was dating a stone butch, who wouldn’t “allow” me to touch her below the shoulders.
This reader misunderstood and thought that I, as a femme, didn’t want to or was uncomfortable touching a butch lover. But of course, nothing could be further from the truth. After a few emails, I explained myself to her and she to me.
After we both realized it was a simple misunderstanding and that we are both on the same side of this issue, so to speak she sent this email. It touched me so much it brought tears to my eyes. Very reminiscent in some respect to Stone Butch Blues …. at least in the way that here is a butch from an older generation talking to me. Telling me a little bit about what it was like, back then. It still gives me chills.
It’s because of women like this, that we have the freedom to be ourselves today. Having said that, I asked her permission to share with you part of her email.
That “touch” issue….there’s so very much behind it…Butch or Stone Butch…..
If I may: I can only truly speak for myself…….Life is “different” for BUTCH…..we know early on in life who/whom we are and simply refine that (most do, I did)
Asside from having to “accept” this Gay Life and Fate bestowed upon me…Back then (50′s & 60′s & 70′s)
I had to not only “defend” who/whom I was and am….But constantly and consistently I had to “defend” my
family…tho I was cast out….I had to “defend” every woman I was with from the ignorant…I have had to “defend”
my entire life and (here’s the key)..”to never submit” to anyone, any people, place or thing for my right to be as I am.
Hence…Butch is not “submissive”…Never on my back….always On Top…On Top of everything…everything I’ve ever done
I had to Be On Top……My Life is “Personal”….My Life is “Private”….what goes on behind the door belongs to me and my partner…no one else.
I do not put my woman on display in public….I hold the greatest of respect for women…and all should be treated like princesses…
and should not settle for less than, ever.In Private….I must say….not every Femme..knows “how” to seduce a Butch…and laying on my back is not an option…
It’s the “Masculine” energy we possess….We are NOT MEN…don’t want to be MEN….But we are Pure Masculine Energy
in a female package…intuitive…understanding of another womans needs…..When the Masculine Energy Clashes with a Feminine Energy….we become a mess….but hold our heads….
A Femme renders us so to our knees…..Just a Femme’s presence….can make a Butch come unglued…However….
that Feminine Energy you have also drives a Butch to “take”….even to a Femme’s seduction…it can’t be helped, we flip…
We flip her over because of the “adore” we hold…and love her to death….In loving Femme….she responds to our needs…we create that space for her to let go….at the same time, all of Femme’s responses
are exactly as we need…hence we make love for “2″…..and just as exhausted as you are…so are we…to “touch” ….we’d have
to start from the beginning again…..and Sometimes, Femme just wants to go down….in that respect, we are not MEN…Men are
submissive…..we are Female…but have just come and climaxed just as hard as Femme has……
And…..Psychologically….sometimes…it’s simply a “bonding issue”………..Be light….enjoy your lives together…..God knows, I have fought long and hard for many to have the right to be….from that Young Female
wanting to wear a Tux to her Prom Dance to a 5th grader who realizes he or she is gay and is treated with the same respect as
the other kids……It was worth every ounce of sacrifice and defense I and others put forth….
At this point in my life….I no longer have to “defend” my right to be…..I simply AM.
wow, beautiful….
To an old-school butch from a young, old-fashioned butch, YES. Absolutely beautifully articulated.
There it is. Simply defined.
I got chills.
Human dignity eloquently defined. Beautiful strength.
*curtseys* Thank you kindly.
Well said Butch.
I must have read this four or five times now. Thank you for articulating and for being butch in a hostile environment. Much love and adoration for you and all the butches out there.
When ever someone speaks first hand about such experiences from such a deep rooted place (“the 5os, 60s and 70s”) of deep personal history/experiences I always find it very humbling to be the listener. I know I posted before but wanted to add a sincere thank you for sharing your past and walking us through a bit of your journey. I have tremendous admiration for the inner strength of butch women in our overly judgmental society. I personally stop dead in my tracks in awe whenever I cross paths with a butch. Our bartender was butch and I was like a school girl from a far- she noticed- smile back and looked at her ring which I totally did not see until then but she did not do it in a way to embarass me. Again – strong integrity of a butch. Your post increased my already strong respect towards the journey of butch women. Best wishes.
*goosebumps*
Thank you for sharing this, you can feel her pain and spirit so clearly.
As a young butch, this made me feel a lot. It made me feel grateful to this anonymous butch for all she and her generation did for us. It made made me want to cry for a few reasons, but I didn’t. It made me ache for a femme someday, like Sasha that will love me like she loves Remi.
Thank you dear anonymous. Thank you.
Couldnt have said it better myself. Wow, those were some powerful words. Powerful words my friend. Thank you for sharing.
This was better said then I could ever hope to articulate for myself. But as a butch, I felt like someone had reached inside my soul and explained myself to the world. Thank you.
God Bless each and everyone of you for your amazing expressions, I’m truly flattered….Jesse
wow, that was amazing. simply amazing.
A lesson from an unspoken hero. I came out in a time where butch/femme relationships were looked down upon. A truly sad time in lesbian history. It was my fortune to have met a few powerful butch women, who came of age during the 50-60′s. Two lessons have stood out, thirty years later. First a butch knows she has to be tough on the outside to fight for her existence, her femme will always create a place at home where the roles reverse. A femme, inside the confines of the home has all the power to take away the hurts of the world outside. A true butch understands and respects this. The other lesson is to never forget the butches who fought for the right of the young “butches” to march in the parades. It was because of the beatings, both physical and mental, that the youing kids can do this.
No disrespect to the young crowd. Your struggle is not new, nor is it near as bad as those who went before you. Read Stone Butch Blues, visit with older lesbians and learn the history of your people. Pay respect to those who made your life easier.
Kim Beautifully written!!!!
I haven’t spoken for a long time on any topic here on CCL…but, this is one I have passion for!
Thank you all!
I am butch and I look butch and I work in an environment that deals with the public everyday. Therefore, I am scrutinized everyday by customers and sometimes co-workers. It’s difficult but, I manage because I am who I am and know there are those that appreciate me…the “Femmes” that I love and that love and appreciate me!
Thanks, Kim!
…and, I definitely don’t want to disrespect the older Butche’s that made my life easier! We, (the younger one’s) are truly indebted to all of you! Thanks………